AI Website Builders Are Getting Really Good. Here’s Why Your Store Still Needs an Expert

Last week, Adobe took the stage at Adobe MAX in Miami and showed off a wave of new AI features. One of them is Firefly Builder, a tool that turns a few sentences into an interactive website prototype. No code, no designer, a few minutes.

I know people who were there, and you know we had to spend some time talking about it. Not just the tools themselves, but the reaction. A lot of creatives are worried. Some are angry. And honestly? I get it. Even Adobe opened its keynote by acknowledging that, in the wake of AI, things feel uncertain.

And it’s not just Adobe. Shopify launched Canvas in October, a space where merchants chat with its Sidekick AI and watch their store rebuild itself in real time. Wix, Squarespace and Hostinger all have AI website builders too.

So if you’re a store owner, it’s a fair question: if AI can build a website in minutes, why would you hire someone like me?

Here’s my honest take, from someone who builds Shopify stores for a living and uses AI every single day.

 

What Adobe actually announced (and what it didn’t)

Firefly Builder is currently in private beta. It lets you describe a website, app or presentation in plain language and get back an interactive, on-brand prototype, with no code needed for that first version.

That’s genuinely exciting. I can already see myself using tools like this to show a client a design direction faster. That’s a real upside, and I think Adobe deserves credit for pushing it.

But notice the word prototype. Even early reviewers point out that, for now, Firefly Builder is a prototyping tool, not a full website builder you publish and sell from. And that difference matters a lot more than it sounds. (More on that below.) Just because Firefly Builder can’t build an entire site yet, it doesn’t mean there aren’t loads of other AI website builders out there that DO offer it. Just last week the owner of the pilates studio I go to proudly told me the guy she hired to do the website did it all through AI (I had interesting thoughts go through my head at that moment as you can imagine!).

 

Who AI website builders actually threaten

I’ll be honest: I don’t think AI threatens everyone in web design equally. In my opinion, it’s mostly a concern for three groups.

  1. People who compete on price. If your offer is “a website for $500,” you’re now competing with a tool that’s free or close to it. AI is very good at fast, cheap and good enough. It’s hard to beat it at its own game.
  2. Beginners who are still learning. Every expert was a beginner once, me included. But the entry-level work that helped people learn (simple sites, basic templates, quick fixes) is exactly what AI does best. The learning curve just got steeper.
  3. Experts who refuse to adapt. Years of experience won’t protect you if you’re still spending hours on work a tool can do in minutes. Clients want to work with someone who knows the tools and uses them well.

 

Why AI-built websites all start to look the same

Ever since AI became more wildly available, I’ve been using different models and trying out different tasks. Of course out of curiosity I’ve tried to brief it on making websites. The first site I generated looked great. The fifth one looks… exactly like the first one.

AI applies a formula, it knows what websites generally look like, and it gives you that, again and again. What it doesn’t have is context: who your customers are, why they hesitate before buying, which products carry your margins, what makes your brand different from the five other stores selling something similar.

And first impressions are fast. Researchers at Carleton University in Ottawa found that people judge a website’s visual appeal in about 50 milliseconds. That’s before they’ve read a single word.

Google’s own research found that people tend to rate familiar-looking designs as more beautiful. That’s exactly why AI-generated sites look “fine”: familiar is what AI does best. But familiar is the floor, not the ceiling. Knowing where to follow conventions (navigation, cart, checkout) and where to stand out (your story, your photos, how your products are presented) is the actual job. It’s all about using your own professional judgement case by case, and the answer is different for every store.

A website that looks like everyone else’s is easy to forget. And a store that’s easy to forget doesn’t sell.

 

A prototype is not a store

This is the part most AI demos skip. A beautiful homepage is maybe 10% of what makes an online store work. The rest is everything behind it:

  • Products set up properly: variants, collections, filters, product details that answer your customers’ questions
  • Shipping, taxes and payments: rates that make sense, the right tax settings (GST, HST, QST if you sell in Canada), a checkout that doesn’t lose people
  • Apps and integrations: email marketing, reviews, inventory, your accounting or ERP system, Amazon
  • Migrations: moving products, customers and order history without breaking your SEO along the way
  • Speed, accessibility and mobile: the things customers feel but never see
  • Languages and markets: for many of my clients, a store that works properly in both English and French
  • Security: Are you protected against hacks and security flaws?

Even Shopify’s own AI store builder will give you a solid starting layout. It won’t make these decisions for you, and it won’t know when something is set up in a way that quietly costs you sales.

 

The person who DIYs with AI was never my client (and that’s okay)

I’ll say this kindly: someone who says “never mind, I’ll just use AI to build my website” was probably never going to invest thousands of dollars in a store build in the first place.

And that’s completely fine! If you’re testing a product idea, launching your very first store or working with a tiny budget, an AI website builder is a great place to start. I’d honestly recommend it.

But business owners who invest in their store aren’t paying for pages. They’re paying for judgment: the experience to know what will work for their customers, the knowledge to set things up properly the first time and someone to call when something breaks. A store owner who was ready to invest in that isn’t going to switch to a free or cheap builder, write a prompt and hope for the best.

 

There’s a big difference between a website built by AI and a website built by an expert who uses AI.

An AI-built website hands every decision to a formula: the layout, the copy, the structure. An AI-powered website is still built by a person who knows your business. AI just takes the repetitive work off their plate, so more of their time goes into the decisions that make your store yours.

Let me be clear about one thing: I’m not going to promise you a website in a day. Good work still takes time. Strategy, design decisions, feedback rounds and testing all need it, and I don’t think that should be rushed.

What AI changes is where that time goes.

I use AI for the grunt work: formatting product spreadsheets for imports, cleaning up messy SKUs, mapping data between systems, drafting checklists, smoothing out repetitive tasks. Work that used to take me hours and added zero creative value.

I don’t use it to replace the creative part: the strategy, the design, the decisions about your brand. That’s where the hours I save now go.

That’s the sweet spot: AI does the heavy lifting behind the scenes, and a human makes every decision your customers actually see and feel. I wrote about this in my last post, How to Build Trust in Your Online Store in the Age of AI (ADD-TRUST-POST-LINK). Customers don’t mind that a business uses AI. They mind when it’s obvious it was half-assed. The same goes for your website.

I’m not alone in this. Adobe’s 2026 study of nearly 2,000 creatives found that 86% say AI has been positive for their work, and 38% use it daily. On the business side, AI use among U.S. small businesses climbed to 66% this year, and a U.S. Chamber of Commerce Foundation study found that most small business workers use AI to boost productivity rather than to automate jobs away.

How is that good for you? 73% of small business owners in a Goldman Sachs survey said they’d benefit from more training and resources to actually make AI work for them. That’s the real value of working with someone who’s fluent in these tools. You get the benefits without having to become an AI expert yourself.

 

Hiring a Shopify expert? How to tell if they use AI well (or just cut corners)

These days, almost every web designer uses AI in some way, so that’s not really the question anymore. The question is how they use it. Some signs are easy to spot before you hire someone. Others only show up once the project is underway, which is exactly why the questions below are worth asking up front.

Uses AI Well Cuts corners with AI
Timeline
Realistic, with time for strategy, feedback rounds and testing
Promises a full store in a day or two
Getting started
Asks lots of questions about your customers, products and goals first
Jumps straight to a quote or a design
Past Work
Every store looks different and fits its brand
Their stores all look alike, or like templates you’ve seen elsewhere
Copy and product content
Client stores read like each brand, with accurate details
Generic text that could fit any store
Transparency
Tells you where they use AI and what they check by hand
Vague about their process, or hides that they use AI at all
Your Data
Careful about what business and customer info goes into AI tools
No clear answer when you ask
Data Imports
Uses AI to speed things up, then reviews every product
Wrong prices, missing variants or empty fields
After Launch
Can explain every part of your store and why it was built that way
Can’t explain why something works the way it does

Questions to ask before you hire:

A good expert will be happy to answer all of these. If someone gets defensive, that tells you something too.

A word of caution: fully custom websites built with AI

There’s one kind of AI-built website I’m more cautious about than any template: a website coded entirely from scratch with AI, without a platform like Shopify, Squarespace, Wix or Webflow underneath.

In theory, it sounds great. You “own” your website, and nothing ties you to a platform. (I wrote about what owning your website really means in You Don’t Own Your Website? The Truth About Shopify, Squarespace, and Platform Myths.)

In practice, there are trade-offs most clients don’t hear about up front:

  • You’ll need the same developer for every change. Nobody else knows how the code was put together, and sometimes not even the person who prompted it.
  • There’s no platform support. On Shopify, you can reach support 24/7. With a custom build, your support is one person’s inbox.
  • There’s no documentation. No help centre, no community forums, no tutorials. When something goes wrong (and at some point, something always does), you’re starting from zero.
  • Security, updates and hosting are on you. A platform handles these behind the scenes. With a custom build, someone has to stay on top of them.

To be clear, custom websites aren’t bad, and for some businesses they’re the right choice. But you should know what you’re signing up for before you decide, not after. If someone offers to build your store from scratch with AI, ask who will maintain it, what happens if they’re unavailable, and where you’d turn if something breaks.

AI website builder vs. budget designer vs. AI-powered expert

AI website builder Budget designer AI-powered expert
Upfront cost
Free to a low monthly fee
A few hundred dollars
An investment based on your scope
Time to first draft
Minutes
Days to weeks
Weeks, with strategy built in
Unique to your brand
Rarely
Often a lightly edited template
Yes
Strategy and conversions
Generic best practices
Limited
Built around your customers
Products, shipping, taxes, apps
You do it yourself
Often basic
Set up properly
Migration and SEO
Can be worked on
Sometimes
Planned so you don’t lose rankings
Support after launch
None
Varies, often pricy retainers
Someone who knows your store
Best For
Testing an idea, very small budgets
Simple sites
Stores that need to grow

So, will AI replace web designers?

Maybe I’ll be proven wrong in a few years. But right now? I think AI will replace the parts of web design that were always a formula. And honestly, good riddance to some of them.

What it can’t replace (yet) is context, judgment and accountability. Knowing your customers. Knowing why a store isn’t converting. Knowing which conventions to follow and when to break them. Being the person who answers when something goes wrong.

The best stores I see in the next few years won’t be built by AI or by humans. They’ll be built by experts who know how to use AI well.

Frequently asked questions

Can AI build a Shopify store? AI can build the starting point. Shopify’s AI store builder and its newer Canvas tool can generate layouts and copy from a prompt. You’ll still need to set up products, shipping, taxes, payments and apps properly, and test everything before launch. That’s where most of the work (and most of the mistakes) happens.

Does Shopify have an AI website builder? Yes. Shopify can generate a store theme from a description of your business, and its AI assistant, Sidekick, can help edit your store through chat. They’re great for a first draft, but they don’t replace strategy or a proper setup.

Is Adobe Firefly Builder a website builder? Not exactly. Firefly Builder, announced at Adobe MAX 2026, creates interactive prototypes of websites, apps and presentations from natural-language prompts. It’s in private beta and is designed for prototyping, not for publishing and running an online store.

Will AI replace web designers? AI is replacing the most repetitive, formula-based parts of web design, and it puts pressure on designers who compete mainly on price. Experienced designers who bring strategy and context, and who use AI to work more efficiently, are in a much stronger position.

Should I use an AI website builder or hire a Shopify expert? If you’re testing an idea or have a very small budget, an AI website builder is a great start. If your online store is a real growth channel for your business, an expert will set it up properly, make it stand out and save you costly mistakes.

Do Shopify experts use AI? The good ones do. AI handles repetitive tasks like data imports and formatting, which leaves more time for strategy, design and testing.

Is a custom website built with AI better than Shopify? Not necessarily. A custom-coded website can feel like you own more of it, but you depend on the developer who built it for every change, and you don’t get platform support or documentation when something goes wrong. For most online stores, a platform like Shopify is easier to maintain and grow.

Not sure where your store stands?

Whether your store was built by AI, by a designer or by you at 2 a.m., my store audit looks at it the way your customers do: design, product pages, setup and the small details that turn visitors into buyers. You’ll get a clear list of what’s working and what to fix first.

Sources

Receive more tips and insights on how to leverage your website in our monthly newsletter: